{"filters":{"category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","party_side":"granted_or_partial","party_side_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью или частично","instance":"","instance_label":"Все судебные инстанции","region":"Москва","region_label":"Москва"},"counts":{"total_acts":228,"classified_axis":228,"unclassified_axis":0,"merits_total":131,"no_merits_n":60,"effect_total":39,"side_total":66},"headline":{"party_side":"granted_or_partial","label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью или частично","denominator_label":"актов с разрешением требования по существу","k":70,"n":131,"n_word":"судебного акта","pct":53.4,"pct_ru":"53,4 %","ci_low":44.9,"ci_high":61.8,"ci_ru":"44,9–61,8 %","gate_min":30,"gate_passed":true,"caveat":null},"claim_breakdown":[{"code":"granted","label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","n":63,"pct":33.0,"pct_ru":"33,0 %","ci_low":26.7,"ci_high":39.9,"ci_ru":"26,7–39,9 %"},{"code":"partial","label":"Требование удовлетворено частично","n":7,"pct":3.7,"pct_ru":"3,7 %","ci_low":1.8,"ci_high":7.4,"ci_ru":"1,8–7,4 %"},{"code":"denied","label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","n":61,"pct":31.9,"pct_ru":"31,9 %","ci_low":25.7,"ci_high":38.8,"ci_ru":"25,7–38,8 %"},{"code":"no_merits","label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","n":60,"pct":31.4,"pct_ru":"31,4 %","ci_low":25.3,"ci_high":38.3,"ci_ru":"25,3–38,3 %"}],"effect_breakdown":[{"code":"upheld","label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","n":34,"pct":87.2,"pct_ru":"87,2 %","ci_low":73.3,"ci_high":94.4,"ci_ru":"73,3–94,4 %"},{"code":"reversed","label":"Судебный акт отменён","n":3,"pct":7.7,"pct_ru":"7,7 %","ci_low":2.7,"ci_high":20.3,"ci_ru":"2,7–20,3 %"},{"code":"modified","label":"Судебный акт изменён","n":0,"pct":0.0,"pct_ru":"0,0 %","ci_low":0.0,"ci_high":9.0,"ci_ru":"0,0–9,0 %"},{"code":"remanded","label":"Дело направлено на новое рассмотрение","n":2,"pct":5.1,"pct_ru":"5,1 %","ci_low":1.4,"ci_high":16.9,"ci_ru":"1,4–16,9 %"}],"sample_cases":[{"id":"1a900d62-c3f3-4559-a8f6-726e958e9cf3","case_number":"А40-58201/2026","court_name":"9 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-30","case_date_ru":"30.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_LIABLE","outcome_label":"Привлечён к ответственности, постановление оставлено в силе","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/1a900d62-c3f3-4559-a8f6-726e958e9cf3","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/7b7313db-5845-45f5-8488-fe4af86411ee"},{"id":"d3a68e31-da80-401f-a1b5-6a7032622fb3","case_number":"А40-345110/2025","court_name":"9 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-30","case_date_ru":"30.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_REDUCED","outcome_label":"Административное наказание смягчено","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Москва","amount_rub":800000.0,"case_url":"/case/d3a68e31-da80-401f-a1b5-6a7032622fb3","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/dc6464f7-a63d-400e-9fef-9aab849c5986"},{"id":"f07f408c-3443-438e-b3c3-21841ff4fc0a","case_number":"А40-344770/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-25","case_date_ru":"25.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/f07f408c-3443-438e-b3c3-21841ff4fc0a","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/03347878-3ba8-46e6-93b0-dc34cb6e9cc9"},{"id":"c9ec8132-4012-4553-8b1f-985deb5405db","case_number":"А40-282868/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-25","case_date_ru":"25.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/c9ec8132-4012-4553-8b1f-985deb5405db","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/3454e922-c531-4bd7-a292-fa1dc9bbc2f1"},{"id":"f6149a00-75c4-4271-8afa-c5c7570dd1a8","case_number":"А40-243793/2025","court_name":"9 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-25","case_date_ru":"25.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"FNS_VICTORY","outcome_label":"Налоговый орган выиграл","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/f6149a00-75c4-4271-8afa-c5c7570dd1a8","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/9f9a7f85-2092-4e76-a5b6-9a7ec949faf8"},{"id":"15718fe5-c7f2-4c3c-a0e6-b693fe65330e","case_number":"А40-58418/2026","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-04","case_date_ru":"04.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_LIABLE","outcome_label":"Привлечён к ответственности, постановление оставлено в силе","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/15718fe5-c7f2-4c3c-a0e6-b693fe65330e","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/984340b9-be2a-4e61-9cf7-2ee035ba8091"},{"id":"12c0ff22-b4d7-4a99-bc7b-06982bce8c6a","case_number":"А40-355588/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-03","case_date_ru":"03.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"PROCEDURAL","outcome_label":"Процессуальное определение","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/12c0ff22-b4d7-4a99-bc7b-06982bce8c6a","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/534ae973-8e03-4d58-91ed-807299056749"},{"id":"6ff395f8-9447-4dbb-bd5a-dc02fef20272","case_number":"А40-289057/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-26","case_date_ru":"26.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_REDUCED","outcome_label":"Административное наказание смягчено","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Москва","amount_rub":13272645.76,"case_url":"/case/6ff395f8-9447-4dbb-bd5a-dc02fef20272","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/3b37e86e-ce98-410d-9a21-7f428c2e6ecd"},{"id":"5bbb3cc2-60ef-4db3-8d55-68d1f142235d","case_number":"А40-316934/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-25","case_date_ru":"25.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_LIABLE","outcome_label":"Привлечён к ответственности, постановление оставлено в силе","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/5bbb3cc2-60ef-4db3-8d55-68d1f142235d","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/4f959224-5900-4a03-96c5-cac1eb1ff7c8"},{"id":"64fad20a-0be1-412f-b1d3-caf24a14361d","case_number":"А40-151394/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-25","case_date_ru":"25.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"ACTIONS_UNLAWFUL","outcome_label":"Действия органа признаны незаконными","claim_result":"granted","claim_result_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","act_effect":"reversed","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт отменён","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/64fad20a-0be1-412f-b1d3-caf24a14361d","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/d9e58575-444a-42a1-821d-92e35b4e265e"},{"id":"07c7967d-31f4-4712-aa27-d7f80a04e2fa","case_number":"А40-314153/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-21","case_date_ru":"21.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"ACTIONS_UPHELD","outcome_label":"В удовлетворении заявления отказано","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/07c7967d-31f4-4712-aa27-d7f80a04e2fa","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/711acc67-d6bc-4de4-8ba4-03ed0531636e"},{"id":"1a071c11-c3c3-44ba-b845-33a8b476e386","case_number":"А40-251692/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-21","case_date_ru":"21.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"ACTIONS_UNLAWFUL","outcome_label":"Действия органа признаны незаконными","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/1a071c11-c3c3-44ba-b845-33a8b476e386","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/d7100680-4efb-4317-bfbd-60be00ada852"},{"id":"17d39aa5-987f-425c-942b-94c2a2907440","case_number":"А40-80089/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-20","case_date_ru":"20.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_LIABLE","outcome_label":"Привлечён к ответственности, постановление оставлено в силе","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Москва","amount_rub":1621659.39,"case_url":"/case/17d39aa5-987f-425c-942b-94c2a2907440","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/07a6017d-a8e8-4e01-90e3-623daa32f508"},{"id":"1d34448f-dd2d-4333-b015-a17f2d02ff36","case_number":"А40-358902/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-05","case_date_ru":"05.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/1d34448f-dd2d-4333-b015-a17f2d02ff36","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/cbed8308-c879-4392-b1bd-9b78c32eae4c"},{"id":"37729a8e-909c-4bb1-bfd5-a1d2690593ee","case_number":"А40-225416/2025","court_name":"9 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-28","case_date_ru":"28.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"BUSINESS_VICTORY","outcome_label":"Заявитель выиграл","claim_result":"granted","claim_result_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Москва","amount_rub":3643197.0,"case_url":"/case/37729a8e-909c-4bb1-bfd5-a1d2690593ee","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/90b294a7-ff2b-424a-ab50-8057ec741589"}],"links":{"builder_url":"/q/?category=tax_other&region=%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B2%D0%B0&party_side=granted_or_partial","json_url":"/q/sample.json?category=tax_other&region=%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B2%D0%B0&party_side=granted_or_partial","csv_url":"/q/sample.csv?category=tax_other&region=%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B2%D0%B0&party_side=granted_or_partial"}}