{"filters":{"category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","party_side":"granted_or_partial","party_side_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью или частично","instance":"","instance_label":"Все судебные инстанции","region":"Московская область","region_label":"Московская область"},"counts":{"total_acts":96,"classified_axis":96,"unclassified_axis":0,"merits_total":52,"no_merits_n":31,"effect_total":10,"side_total":15},"headline":{"party_side":"granted_or_partial","label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью или частично","denominator_label":"актов с разрешением требования по существу","k":13,"n":52,"n_word":"судебных актов","pct":25.0,"pct_ru":"25,0 %","ci_low":15.2,"ci_high":38.2,"ci_ru":"15,2–38,2 %","gate_min":30,"gate_passed":true,"caveat":null},"claim_breakdown":[{"code":"granted","label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","n":11,"pct":13.3,"pct_ru":"13,3 %","ci_low":7.6,"ci_high":22.2,"ci_ru":"7,6–22,2 %"},{"code":"partial","label":"Требование удовлетворено частично","n":2,"pct":2.4,"pct_ru":"2,4 %","ci_low":0.7,"ci_high":8.4,"ci_ru":"0,7–8,4 %"},{"code":"denied","label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","n":39,"pct":47.0,"pct_ru":"47,0 %","ci_low":36.6,"ci_high":57.6,"ci_ru":"36,6–57,6 %"},{"code":"no_merits","label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","n":31,"pct":37.3,"pct_ru":"37,3 %","ci_low":27.7,"ci_high":48.1,"ci_ru":"27,7–48,1 %"}],"effect_breakdown":[{"code":"upheld","label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","n":10,"pct":100.0,"pct_ru":"100,0 %","ci_low":72.2,"ci_high":100.0,"ci_ru":"72,2–100,0 %"},{"code":"reversed","label":"Судебный акт отменён","n":0,"pct":0.0,"pct_ru":"0,0 %","ci_low":0.0,"ci_high":27.8,"ci_ru":"0,0–27,8 %"},{"code":"modified","label":"Судебный акт изменён","n":0,"pct":0.0,"pct_ru":"0,0 %","ci_low":0.0,"ci_high":27.8,"ci_ru":"0,0–27,8 %"},{"code":"remanded","label":"Дело направлено на новое рассмотрение","n":0,"pct":0.0,"pct_ru":"0,0 %","ci_low":0.0,"ci_high":27.8,"ci_ru":"0,0–27,8 %"}],"sample_cases":[{"id":"dcad6b92-4d89-425d-bb1b-09c928e58ee2","case_number":"А41-21700/2026","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-08-25","case_date_ru":"25.08.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":1311943.72,"case_url":"/case/dcad6b92-4d89-425d-bb1b-09c928e58ee2","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/15cd002c-10fd-4866-bc0e-7024d10ce372"},{"id":"aa3846c6-95c4-4871-a34a-837e07b49f7a","case_number":"А41-99444/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-17","case_date_ru":"17.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"PROCEDURAL","outcome_label":"Процессуальное определение","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/aa3846c6-95c4-4871-a34a-837e07b49f7a","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/ed6e5d9b-e76c-495c-883b-02c55264737c"},{"id":"4de36a64-962d-4fbd-804b-0b4417a46fc2","case_number":"А41-111252/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-28","case_date_ru":"28.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_REDUCED","outcome_label":"Административное наказание смягчено","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":30000.0,"case_url":"/case/4de36a64-962d-4fbd-804b-0b4417a46fc2","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/251a96e5-48d0-4ed2-812e-af892019eb7a"},{"id":"24739f54-a6f2-4a2c-88d6-8751957309a4","case_number":"А41-119185/2025","court_name":"10 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-04","case_date_ru":"04.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/24739f54-a6f2-4a2c-88d6-8751957309a4","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/38d39e99-9831-4e16-908e-46446102a87d"},{"id":"ae916873-98da-4604-89a9-6384fb4ead1e","case_number":"А41-104805/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-28","case_date_ru":"28.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/ae916873-98da-4604-89a9-6384fb4ead1e","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/b5d8b586-57d7-4513-8c50-e338149d0761"},{"id":"2dbc6c2e-bea9-4345-b5c7-4bdd558b7465","case_number":"А41-111196/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-27","case_date_ru":"27.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"COLLECTION_DENIED","outcome_label":"Во взыскании отказано","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":5951.0,"case_url":"/case/2dbc6c2e-bea9-4345-b5c7-4bdd558b7465","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/3a621076-1831-4297-a1dd-c5b233d23cbf"},{"id":"68a0f41b-21bf-4638-b115-5a3125b4285a","case_number":"А41-23347/2026","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-23","case_date_ru":"23.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"COLLECTION_DENIED","outcome_label":"Во взыскании отказано","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":0.0,"case_url":"/case/68a0f41b-21bf-4638-b115-5a3125b4285a","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/34dd7612-01f6-4e67-aba7-597c148e0446"},{"id":"ef1dad65-1349-4284-add2-4e31f271a660","case_number":"А41-80099/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-22","case_date_ru":"22.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/ef1dad65-1349-4284-add2-4e31f271a660","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/ae72e647-1843-47cc-bdf9-31f879fe9087"},{"id":"27d23a2d-bf4d-484f-8f3a-f439e7d78b8f","case_number":"А41-84847/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-03-31","case_date_ru":"31.03.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"BUSINESS_VICTORY","outcome_label":"Заявитель выиграл","claim_result":"granted","claim_result_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":50000.0,"case_url":"/case/27d23a2d-bf4d-484f-8f3a-f439e7d78b8f","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/3d0fbb4f-9aba-4403-99fb-639529709a2f"},{"id":"fafa8d9f-cf37-4b29-bb3c-e9edfa3c22e4","case_number":"А41-28502/2026","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-03-19","case_date_ru":"19.03.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"PROCEDURAL","outcome_label":"Процессуальное определение","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/fafa8d9f-cf37-4b29-bb3c-e9edfa3c22e4","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/aac81ebe-9c90-4423-9c08-2133649568ac"},{"id":"768924b7-c7c1-408c-adc0-cfbdc8381a57","case_number":"А41-23085/2026","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-03-11","case_date_ru":"11.03.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"PROCEDURAL","outcome_label":"Процессуальное определение","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/768924b7-c7c1-408c-adc0-cfbdc8381a57","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/5b823a8f-38bb-4324-bc3d-3465e87bc520"},{"id":"79865a9b-371c-4f88-a177-f584653fa091","case_number":"А41-111189/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-02-16","case_date_ru":"16.02.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"COLLECTION_DENIED","outcome_label":"Во взыскании отказано","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":0.0,"case_url":"/case/79865a9b-371c-4f88-a177-f584653fa091","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/97f3cc5d-7a35-4a33-898e-9de661d44ac2"},{"id":"aeea5cd4-09d1-46fe-bde2-5d55c39a5d00","case_number":"А41-111192/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-02-16","case_date_ru":"16.02.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"COLLECTION_DENIED","outcome_label":"Во взыскании отказано","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":0.0,"case_url":"/case/aeea5cd4-09d1-46fe-bde2-5d55c39a5d00","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/84ab32ac-c63e-4acd-88fe-ccb134b54305"},{"id":"b16ee4b9-a8ac-4772-b6f4-bff2157b4e78","case_number":"А41-111193/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд Московской области","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-02-05","case_date_ru":"05.02.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"COLLECTION_DENIED","outcome_label":"Во взыскании отказано","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":0.0,"case_url":"/case/b16ee4b9-a8ac-4772-b6f4-bff2157b4e78","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/8b2421ec-c7ef-458d-a922-53e19fb4f53b"},{"id":"b5f24c6f-0e5e-47bd-9247-e8372bcbe814","case_number":"А41-60850/2025","court_name":"10 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-02-03","case_date_ru":"03.02.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"PROCEDURAL","outcome_label":"Процессуальное определение","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"Московская область","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/b5f24c6f-0e5e-47bd-9247-e8372bcbe814","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/a1996fe2-d5a4-4277-a66c-838553111442"}],"links":{"builder_url":"/q/?category=tax_other&region=%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F+%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%81%D1%82%D1%8C&party_side=granted_or_partial","json_url":"/q/sample.json?category=tax_other&region=%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F+%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%81%D1%82%D1%8C&party_side=granted_or_partial","csv_url":"/q/sample.csv?category=tax_other&region=%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F+%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%81%D1%82%D1%8C&party_side=granted_or_partial"}}