{"filters":{"category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","party_side":"granted_or_partial","party_side_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью или частично","instance":"","instance_label":"Все судебные инстанции","region":"г. Москва","region_label":"г. Москва"},"counts":{"total_acts":112,"classified_axis":112,"unclassified_axis":0,"merits_total":71,"no_merits_n":29,"effect_total":11,"side_total":21},"headline":{"party_side":"granted_or_partial","label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью или частично","denominator_label":"актов с разрешением требования по существу","k":35,"n":71,"n_word":"судебного акта","pct":49.3,"pct_ru":"49,3 %","ci_low":38.0,"ci_high":60.7,"ci_ru":"38,0–60,7 %","gate_min":30,"gate_passed":true,"caveat":null},"claim_breakdown":[{"code":"granted","label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","n":31,"pct":31.0,"pct_ru":"31,0 %","ci_low":22.8,"ci_high":40.6,"ci_ru":"22,8–40,6 %"},{"code":"partial","label":"Требование удовлетворено частично","n":4,"pct":4.0,"pct_ru":"4,0 %","ci_low":1.6,"ci_high":9.8,"ci_ru":"1,6–9,8 %"},{"code":"denied","label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","n":36,"pct":36.0,"pct_ru":"36,0 %","ci_low":27.3,"ci_high":45.8,"ci_ru":"27,3–45,8 %"},{"code":"no_merits","label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","n":29,"pct":29.0,"pct_ru":"29,0 %","ci_low":21.0,"ci_high":38.5,"ci_ru":"21,0–38,5 %"}],"effect_breakdown":[{"code":"upheld","label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","n":8,"pct":72.7,"pct_ru":"72,7 %","ci_low":43.4,"ci_high":90.3,"ci_ru":"43,4–90,3 %"},{"code":"reversed","label":"Судебный акт отменён","n":2,"pct":18.2,"pct_ru":"18,2 %","ci_low":5.1,"ci_high":47.7,"ci_ru":"5,1–47,7 %"},{"code":"modified","label":"Судебный акт изменён","n":0,"pct":0.0,"pct_ru":"0,0 %","ci_low":0.0,"ci_high":25.9,"ci_ru":"0,0–25,9 %"},{"code":"remanded","label":"Дело направлено на новое рассмотрение","n":1,"pct":9.1,"pct_ru":"9,1 %","ci_low":1.6,"ci_high":37.7,"ci_ru":"1,6–37,7 %"}],"sample_cases":[{"id":"82915ffa-c52f-405d-9b7d-d687aafccca8","case_number":"А40-57748/2026","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-08","case_date_ru":"08.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"ACTIONS_PARTIAL","outcome_label":"Требования удовлетворены частично","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":1270483.29,"case_url":"/case/82915ffa-c52f-405d-9b7d-d687aafccca8","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/c7f87bcc-e0b1-4888-83e1-b38a83bdf104"},{"id":"f15346e1-db21-408c-95e6-862963f8c82d","case_number":"А40-43005/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-06-04","case_date_ru":"04.06.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"FNS_VICTORY","outcome_label":"Налоговый орган выиграл","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/f15346e1-db21-408c-95e6-862963f8c82d","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/e32dbc44-e2d0-48e5-8eea-76cf841b9116"},{"id":"324e3fb0-86a7-4b7a-ac5a-4818f5bad55f","case_number":"А40-240200/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-21","case_date_ru":"21.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_RELEASED","outcome_label":"Освобождён от ответственности, постановление отменено","claim_result":"granted","claim_result_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/324e3fb0-86a7-4b7a-ac5a-4818f5bad55f","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/dcb3d516-4a91-4394-ad04-5b3db43ba544"},{"id":"a3d15987-b9b9-4eb9-86df-66a20aac54a8","case_number":"А40-270836/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-14","case_date_ru":"14.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/a3d15987-b9b9-4eb9-86df-66a20aac54a8","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/fa90dfa4-27e6-403c-b377-8c74d3f150e6"},{"id":"1785ea19-a74a-4059-bcc3-30bd0fb9dea4","case_number":"А40-337405/2025","court_name":"9 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-12","case_date_ru":"12.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_RELEASED","outcome_label":"Освобождён от ответственности, постановление отменено","claim_result":"granted","claim_result_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":2097908.0,"case_url":"/case/1785ea19-a74a-4059-bcc3-30bd0fb9dea4","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/c32c04cf-03eb-40a0-9ed4-ea1f13e4a680"},{"id":"d722cd25-c463-43f1-a204-b94a65c6cdd3","case_number":"А40-270231/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-05-04","case_date_ru":"04.05.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"EP_GRANTED","outcome_label":"Заявление по исполнительному производству удовлетворено","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":1837912.62,"case_url":"/case/d722cd25-c463-43f1-a204-b94a65c6cdd3","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/4a7e7e86-54ed-4c59-b27d-2c558347ccb9"},{"id":"d659bfd4-d1c1-40c8-bf4a-bc4fbb6147d4","case_number":"А40-91979/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-29","case_date_ru":"29.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"FNS_VICTORY","outcome_label":"Налоговый орган выиграл","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"upheld","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт оставлен без изменения","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/d659bfd4-d1c1-40c8-bf4a-bc4fbb6147d4","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/4b725cd1-391b-4b54-9948-68a7253e7adb"},{"id":"9fef2b75-5888-4c68-8191-4bb1a2903d98","case_number":"А40-151411/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-20","case_date_ru":"20.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"ACTIONS_UNLAWFUL","outcome_label":"Действия органа признаны незаконными","claim_result":"granted","claim_result_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/9fef2b75-5888-4c68-8191-4bb1a2903d98","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/4f0013b9-38be-4134-aac8-2aff644b0e89"},{"id":"b3f41560-fa77-4610-b544-40b829ffb0b6","case_number":"А40-284101/2025","court_name":"9 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-04-10","case_date_ru":"10.04.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"ACTIONS_PARTIAL","outcome_label":"Требования удовлетворены частично","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/b3f41560-fa77-4610-b544-40b829ffb0b6","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/23202267-03e4-46fc-a40b-d9da46ae16a3"},{"id":"b4274029-27ef-4420-8cc8-e1923056d87a","case_number":"А40-317048/2025","court_name":"9 арбитражный апелляционный суд","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-03-20","case_date_ru":"20.03.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"ACTIONS_UPHELD","outcome_label":"В удовлетворении заявления отказано","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/b4274029-27ef-4420-8cc8-e1923056d87a","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/ce0c9d9d-8b44-4a46-bf57-223598e92a81"},{"id":"bb998143-b819-45d2-a538-41d03678159e","case_number":"А40-174712/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-03-20","case_date_ru":"20.03.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"PROCEDURAL","outcome_label":"Процессуальное определение","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/bb998143-b819-45d2-a538-41d03678159e","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/7c0d3c93-11f7-40c7-b4fb-b9da00663f94"},{"id":"3a4443a1-98cf-430a-aa2b-a24a718f25f4","case_number":"А40-341714/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-03-05","case_date_ru":"05.03.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"TERMINATED","outcome_label":"Производство прекращено либо оставлено без рассмотрения","claim_result":"no_merits","claim_result_label":"Заявление оставлено без рассмотрения или производство прекращено","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/3a4443a1-98cf-430a-aa2b-a24a718f25f4","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/72d6202e-1729-46fd-a5ae-8e99c0aa57e5"},{"id":"a99bc172-ae56-425f-9f28-7256bf9ae52f","case_number":"А40-318585/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"appeal","court_level_label":"Апелляционная инстанция","case_date":"2026-03-03","case_date_ru":"03.03.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"PROCEDURAL","outcome_label":"Процессуальное определение","claim_result":null,"claim_result_label":"—","act_effect":"reversed","act_effect_label":"Судебный акт отменён","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/a99bc172-ae56-425f-9f28-7256bf9ae52f","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/86c147f7-2e9a-445a-a68c-f57e6782cc6f"},{"id":"b24d4575-38a8-4f8d-b899-ab947f4af724","case_number":"А40-320461/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-02-26","case_date_ru":"26.02.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_RELEASED","outcome_label":"Освобождён от ответственности, постановление отменено","claim_result":"denied","claim_result_label":"В удовлетворении требования отказано","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/b24d4575-38a8-4f8d-b899-ab947f4af724","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/3e8ac93b-cfc8-4771-8cde-650a1ff26ab9"},{"id":"90a6eea8-be4e-4d32-9fd1-d82c6688c653","case_number":"А40-268124/2025","court_name":"Арбитражный суд города Москвы","court_level":"first","court_level_label":"Первая инстанция","case_date":"2026-02-26","case_date_ru":"26.02.2026","category":"tax_other","category_label":"Прочие налоговые споры","outcome":"KOAP_LIABLE","outcome_label":"Привлечён к ответственности, постановление оставлено в силе","claim_result":"granted","claim_result_label":"Требование удовлетворено полностью","act_effect":null,"act_effect_label":"—","region":"г. Москва","amount_rub":null,"case_url":"/case/90a6eea8-be4e-4d32-9fd1-d82c6688c653","source_url":"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/34d7f441-f5bf-4486-8a42-e461b9116315"}],"links":{"builder_url":"/q/?category=tax_other&region=%D0%B3.+%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B2%D0%B0&party_side=granted_or_partial","json_url":"/q/sample.json?category=tax_other&region=%D0%B3.+%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B2%D0%B0&party_side=granted_or_partial","csv_url":"/q/sample.csv?category=tax_other&region=%D0%B3.+%D0%9C%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B2%D0%B0&party_side=granted_or_partial"}}